EP293: Contractor Profit: How to Calculate Equipment ROI Before Buying
Tonight's Episode
Before spending thousands of dollars, contractors need to understand the true cost of equipment ownership, calculate equipment ROI, and determine whether the purchase will actually improve profitability.
Here's what you'll learn in this episode:
• How to calculate equipment ROI before investing in new construction equipment.
• Why the purchase price is only one part of the total cost of equipment ownership.
• How equipment expenses affect contractor profit margins and business profitability.
• How to evaluate the expected return on an equipment investment.
• Why calculating your equipment break-even point matters before making a purchase.
• How to compare buying versus renting construction equipment.
• How to make smarter equipment purchasing decisions based on your company's financial goals.
Before purchasing your next piece of construction equipment, make sure the numbers make sense for your business.
Join the Contractor Profit Blueprint Community:
https://www.skool.com/contractorprofitblueprint/about
Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Transcribed automatically
Just because you can afford to pay $1,500 a month for a truck payment or $1,200 a month for a piece of equipment doesn't mean it makes financial sense to actually do that. Before you go out and spend $60,000 on a new piece of equipment, $80,000 on a new truck, or $50,000 building out a showroom, have you actually done the math to determine whether it's a good investment? Too many contractors make major purchases based on emotion, convenience, or what they think will happen instead of looking at the actual numbers.
Today, we're going to walk through three questions you should ask before making any major business purchase. And then I'll give you two real world examples of how to calculate whether an investment actually makes financial sense. Hey, welcome back to the show. I'm your host, Brad Hebner. I'm a licensed general contractor, author of The Contractor Profit Blueprint. business coach to overwhelmed and stuck contractors who want to boost their profits and regain their freedom by showing them how to charge what they're worth.
Now, you want to make that major purchase, right? You want to buy that new vehicle, piece of equipment, invest in a showroom, whatever it is, you think this is going to, quote, change the game for your business. Now, this topic actually comes from one of my clients. It was a recommendation because they're right in the This happens a lot. I talk to people that have, you know, I look at their P&Ls. Whenever I work with a new contractor, I always have them send their P&Ls in. We look at it, what they got going on, their balance sheet, all that stuff.
And more times than not, there's a lot of equipment that's not being utilized correctly, or they've invested too much money and now they're in over their head. And so now they're like, they have to catch up because they bought this equipment thinking it's going to do something that it actually did not do. So there's three questions that you need to ask or answer rather before you make a major purchase. So number one is what's the true cost? Purchase price, financing, interest, insurance, maintenance, additional overhead, all the stuff that goes into it.
It's really easy to say, oh, this costs X amount per month for the payment and then not calculate anything else into it. So what's the true cost? And factor in all of it. What's the return? What's the actual return it's going to get? Will it increase revenue? Will it generate additional gross profit? Will it reduce expenses? Or will it save on labor? There has to be some type of return other than, well, it's frustrating to rent equipment all the time. That's not a valid reason to buy anything is because you're just frustrated buying it.
There has it has to make mathematical sense. Right. And then lastly, what's the break even? How long until the investment pays for itself? And what happens if you only get half of your expected return? Now, a little forecast or hint here, like half, you know, getting a return or half of return on your investment, a 50 percent return on your investment is like the minimum requirement you should be basing it on. Too many people expect everything to go perfectly. By the way, side note, this is why all your estimates always come in short, because you're bidding jobs perfect, and they never come in perfect.
You have a 10% chance of it coming in perfect, yet you bid 100% of your jobs with perfect execution, right? So there's a little tip into everything you do in your business. Something to keep in mind here, just because you can afford a monthly payment, just because you can afford to pay $1,500 a month for a truck payment or. $1,200 a month for a piece of equipment or whatever it might be, that loan, capital loan investment, doesn't mean it makes financial sense to actually do that. So you do the math and figure out what the ROI is.
Just because you can afford something doesn't mean that it makes sense to actually do it. So here's example number one. You want to buy a skid steer. Now, you can replace this with any piece of equipment. But I got some numbers here just to kind of go through this. And are they going to be exact in your area? No, I mean, guys, just because it doesn't match your exact formula, like let's use our brains here a little bit. OK, I get hate all the time. Well, I don't have to pay that much. My monthly rental is cheaper than that.
Great. Insert your numbers. It doesn't matter. It's an example. I don't know why you have to say this every time I get people arguing. Well, that's not that's not for me. It's an example, guys. It's not it's isn't real life. This is an example. All right. Purchase price for a skid steer, $58,400, right? Call it 60K, whatever. Your down payment, assuming you have the money, $10,000 down. You finance 48.4 at 7% interest for 60 months. Your monthly payment is approximately $958 a month. And then you add in your insurance, maintenance, and storage.
If you have to pay for it, it's estimated $450 a month. your total ownership cash outflow is approximately $1,408 a month. That does not include gas, by the way, right? So like you have to factor in that as an additional, but your gas typically should be as a cost of goods for the job. So if you rent it, if you're renting a piece of equipment right now, it's roughly between $2,300 to $3,000 a month if you do a monthly rental on a piece of equipment. So the question here is how many months a year would you need to use this piece of equipment to justify the cost or to break even?
So based on the $1,408 per month cost, it ends up being $16,900 per year of ownership cash outflow, right? So let's just round it to $17,000. You're going to spend $17,000 a month, I'm sorry, a year to own this piece of equipment. again not including gas or you know repairs so if you rented a piece of equipment it costs you three thousand dollars a month so at two months it's six thousand three months nine so on and so on you would need to be you would need to essentially use the piece of equipment approximately 5.6 months out of the year so let's round it up to six months of out of the year so you would need to be using that equipment at least six months out of the year just to essentially break even on the cost.
Anything over six months, and now it's saving you money, right? If you use it eight months a year, that's 24k, it's saving you, you know, significantly amount of money. If you're using it all year round, even more. So using math here in these formulas we would need to use this at least 5 or six months out of the year in order to make it make sense financially Right If you if your rental is only a month then you have to you have to use it approximately 7.3 months, roughly seven months out of the year in order to make it make sense.
Right. If you only expect to use it three or four months out of the year, then it does not make sense to own the skid steer. It just doesn't make sense financially. Right. So after five years, thing to keep in consideration is that after five years, you own the machine. So now you have actual capital that you could sell the equipment for and make money back, right? This isn't taking all of that in consideration. We're just looking at it from a mainly a cash flow perspective. But as a return on investment, does it make sense?
So the key point here is don't buy equipment based on how often you hope you're going to use it, you need to calculate how often you'll actually use it, Right. And like I said, this doesn't take into consideration like the $10,000 down that you put, you know, resale value, all that depreciation. It's not taking that stuff into consideration, although you certainly could add that into the formula. If it doesn't make sense simply on how much money you're saving from like a rental perspective, you don't even need to calculate the other stuff because it doesn't even make sense.
Too many of you like, man, I really I hate renting equipment. It's just such a pain in the butt. I want to go buy my own skid steer. That is not a good reason to buy a good skid steer. If you're like, well, if we have a skid steer, then we're going to use it more often for more things. Really? Will you? Because what I know happens is whenever you have to go dig three hoes, you know, in the ground and say you have an auger attachment. Most people aren't going to roll their, you know, their skid steer out, unload it, use it to dig three hoes.
They're going to do it by hand. Does it make sense? If you're going to dig 50 holes for a fence, yeah, you would bring out your skid steer. But there's times where you think you're going to use it every time. It now becomes annoying to have to haul this piece of equipment out, find a place to park it on a busy street where you don't have room. You got to, you know, then you got to drop it off and go park it, you know, three blocks down the road or whatever. It becomes now an annoyance of using the equipment.
So like in our mind, oh, this is going to be awesome. I'm going to use this for everything. I'm going to have every attachment possible and it's really going to make everything so much easier. That's not usually what happens. Now, obviously having equipment makes everything a lot easier. There's no argument there. It's financially doesn't make sense. And we use it based on half usage. So just because you think you're going to use it all the time doesn't mean that you're actually going to use it all the time.
So use real math to make this decision is the point of this, right? Not emotions. I mean, that's that's basically like use real math. OK, so example number two. This is what I was talking with my client about. You want to invest in a showroom. Maybe you have a location. You have an office, a building. You know, you want to turn it into a showroom. Maybe you want to add on. Maybe you want to buy an office building that you can use as a showroom. It doesn't really matter. In this scenario, we're going to say you have equipped, you have the showroom or you have a building already.
You have space, but you're going to turn into a showroom and you're willing to invest like fifty thousand dollars to do this. This is different because the math here is not as clean as, you know, renting a piece of equipment. So what's the numbers? Let's say the showroom build out and displays are going to cost you $50,000. Maybe you can get your, you know, let's say it's a kitchen showroom. Maybe you can get your vendors to provide the cabinets for the showroom. They'll pay for it. You get your countertop people, they'll pay for it.
You could save some money and I would recommend doing that. But let's just say your total out cost is $50,000. What you don't take into consideration a lot of times is what's the additional cost? If all of a sudden we have a bunch of extra lights in there, is that going to increase our electricity? Probably. If we have more people coming in and out of the door, does that affect the temperature in the building, which means your equipment's got to run more often? Yes. So like your utilities can actually increase simply by adding the showroom, right?
So, I mean, and then insurance. Like now all of a sudden you've got to increase your insurance. to cover it potentially, because you have more liability and more things there to cover. That can increase your overhead by 2K a month. Again, these are just rough numbers, not saying it's exact. But your additional annual overhead, if you do increase it by 2K, is now $24,000. So that $50,000 initial investment could potentially increase your annual overhead by $24,000. right? So your total investment in one year would be like $74,000 in the first year.
Now, let's say your average kitchen remodel is $75,000 at a 50% gross profit. That means your gross profit per kitchen is $37,500, right? Again, gross profit, not overhead gross profit. So how many additional kitchens would you need to be able to sell using your showroom to make it worth the investment. So if you don't add any additional kitchens, you shouldn't make any money. You lost money, right? If you sold one extra kitchen per year, then that's a $13,500 additional benefit. It's going to take you 3.7 years just to pay for that showroom.
If you sell an additional three kitchens a year because of the showroom, that's $88,500. It's only going to take you seven months to recoup your money. What's harder about stuff like this is that there's no guarantees. like you could invest all this money and it doesn't benefit you whatsoever there's not real hard cost that you can track you know did someone buy from you simply because you had a showroom or they were going to buy from you regardless if you had a showroom but you contributed to the fact that they bought from you because you had a showroom unless you specifically ask that question and track that data you're not going to know right there's there's lots of unknowns that go into this Now, I will tell you just from in general, like having a showroom does add a level of legitimacy to your business.
It also makes your process as much easier. So now you can factor in like an efficiency rating. If people are coming to you to do all the design and all of the selections, then that saves you time, energy, right? So like there's an efficiency reduction there. But can you really track that? Like how many hours you spend? Like if you really had all that data, you could, but it gets a lot more messier with, with stuff like a showroom. So things to consider, you know, will the showroom actually generate additional customers or increase your closing percentage Like I said can it increase the average project size or gross profit So now you add in we say our average ticket 50K Now because we have a showroom we can show them some fancy gadgets and all this whiz bang stuff.
Now they want to add an extra 15K per project because they can see it. Now they like it. So that generated an additional 10 to $15,000 per project, right? So that can increase the average project size. What if you only sell half as many kitchens as expected. How does that, that's that half equation. Could you accomplish the same result with a smaller investment, right? So a showroom doesn't automatically make you money. And this is why this one's challenging. Hey, just a quick timeout from the show.
If you're a frustrated contractor who's dealing with low profit margins, stuck working on the tools every day, or doing free estimates for people who are never going to hire you in the first place, I invite you to my private contractor community, The Profit Club, where contractors, just like you are adding two to three times more profit each year without producing any more jobs and finally getting completely off the tools to never do another free estimate again. So if you're ready to increase your profits, stop doing free estimates and get off the tools, then all you have to do is click the link in the show notes to learn more about the Profit Club and see how it can easily two to three times the cash in your pocket, give you a proven sales process that will convert more jobs with ease and get you off the tools once and for all.
And the best part is you can do all of this without having to produce more jobs than you currently are. Click the link to learn more. Now let's get back to the show. You have to determine how much additional gross profit it needs to generate to justify the investment. So another thing is like showroom costs and sales projections are completely hypothetical. Like, you know, payback estimates include financial or financing taxes and additional staffing costs to get these numbers. So like there's a again, there's a bunch more math that goes into this that we're not even talking about.
So you can't just say, oh, I think it's going to cost me. You know, I can I can maybe spend thirty, forty thousand dollars. Yeah, it makes sense. Let's do it. That's not how you make sound financial business decisions in your business. Like you, you need to use actual math, even if it's very simple, basic, archaic math, you need to use some form of math to make it make sense to make that decision. I was talking with my client who wanted to put a showroom in his space and he brought a designer in and they went hog wild and they're talking about, you know, spending upwards of like $40,000 on this showroom.
And I'm like, hold on. I was like, hold on, pump the brakes here for a second. First of all, that's crazy amount for what you're wanting to do for. I'm not going to give any specifics because I don't want to, you know, I don't want to know who I'm talking about. But I'm like, that's crazy to spend that much money. I said, why don't you actually just do like an MVP, a minimal viable product, meaning do the least amount you could possibly do to see if it even is helpful. Like you don't have to go out and do the best of the best of the best on everything and then hope that it actually pays for itself.
This is what software companies do all the time. They put out an MVP. It's like, here's the minimal viable product that we want to put out. Do people love it or do they hate it? And if they love it, then we can expand and add more features and stuff to it. It's the same thing you do in situations like this, if it makes sense. Now it may not make sense. Like if you have to buy a building to put a showroom in, then you're committed no matter what to the cost of the building, even if you put a small showroom in there, right?
So like there's a cost associated with that. So what is the MVP to be able to pull this off? Are people actually demanding this? Or is it just a wishful thinking on your part? Because you want to be a visionary and you have, you know, grand visions of having your own showroom, even though your product or service doesn't even necessarily need a showroom or your clients don't even care if you have a showroom and it adds no value to your business. So like you can't just make these decisions on a whim.
Oh, it'd be nice. You know, I'd love to have my own skid steer. I would too. I'd love to have a skid steer. I don't need one. So I'm not going to buy one because it doesn't make any sense. Right now. The other thing we need to take consideration is like, do you have a vehicle that can pull your skid steer? Do you have a trailer already? No. Oh, now you got to buy a trailer and now you got to buy a vehicle that can pull it. and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah. And all, and it's a chain reaction of things that go down the line.
You know, I went through this experience with myself, we bought a camper and I did the calculations and I, my truck was able to pull it, but it didn't like it at all. Especially didn't like it on the Hills. I had a Tundra, uh, and the camper was roughly 9,500 pounds. We're at the top end of the payload, uh, and it would pull it, but it didn't like it. And so eventually I went and bought a new pickup truck, right? I went and bought a one-ton. So that was because of initially I thought I was going to get away with a half ton, but it ended up not working out.
And so now I went and bought a bigger vehicle, right? So I didn't have to do that. I wanted to, and I could afford to do that, but I didn't have to do that, right? So like sometimes when you do these things, you do it because you want to, not because you actually need it or because you, it makes sense. It's just, oh, it'd be nice to have this. Right. And then you buy a skid steer and it sits in your yard for eight months out of the year. And then you justify it to yourself. Like, well, whenever we do use it, it's really handy.
Yeah. But financially, that was a terrible decision. It didn't make any sense. One last thing I want to throw in here, completely unrelated. I've had many arguments. If you rent equipment and you say you're going to rent, you're going to do a job, an excavation job or whatever, and you're going to be on this job for a month. And so you rent a piece of equipment, a skid steer for a month, and it costs you 3k to rent that equipment. Nine out of 10 people, 99 out of 100 people say, oh yeah, we add that cost to the estimate, right?
Because it costs us 3k to rent that equipment. So we're going to pass it on to the customer. Makes perfect sense. Then that same person who adds the rental costs into their estimate goes out and buys a piece of equipment. And all of a sudden now they don't want to add any cost of the equipment to the estimate because they see that as a quote overhead. You were already getting 3k a month for renting it. Why would you take that away just because you bought the equipment? Your equipment still has a cost.
Like you still need to charge for it, whether it an hour an hour with an operator or whatever Like you have a hard cost right You have a replacement cost But for whatever reason people want to be like oh my you know it cost me a month And I divide that by how many hours we use and blah blah blah So I only charge the customer, you know, a $500 to use that equipment for the month. Why? Like seriously, why? You would charge 3K. Now you're only going to charge 500 because it doesn't make it. It makes no sense whatsoever.
continue charging what you need to charge or what you can charge. Now, if it's costing you to lose jobs, then yeah, maybe you can back out some of that profit because you don't have that true hard cost, but I promise you, whatever you're charging for your equipment, it costs you way more than that. Way, way more because you're not taking consideration maintenance replacement cost mobilization costs. You know, if you, if you have to pull it, move your equipment five times on one job because you don't need it every day, So you mobilize to the job, you drop it off, you use it for three days, you load it back up, you take it to another job, you bring it back a week later, use it for a day or two, you mobilize again.
You do this three or four times on one job, right? But you're only factoring operation hours. Oh, it's $300 every time we use the equipment. You're not factoring in all the mobilization costs, the time it took the person to drive it, the wear and tear on the vehicle and the equipment. Like all of that gets added in there as well. So a lot of times when people own equipment, their actual efficiency rating goes down. Because now instead of like renting a piece of equipment and leaving it on the job site, or you may have three jobs going and you just rent three skid steers for three different jobs because the customer's paying for it.
Now, because you have your own equipment, you're running around all the time, delivering, loading, unloading, using, loading, unloading, driving. Like you're doing this nonstop. you basically become a full-time equipment transporter. People don't think about that. There's real costs there. So again, even if you can afford it, it may not make sense operationally or financially to actually buy the equipment. These are all things you should take into consideration before you make these types of investments.
So just to recap here, what's the true cost of owning it and factor in as many, many, many things as you possibly can. Again, mobilization costs. What's the return? If I do this, what kind of return am I going to get from it? And then what's the break even? So the takeaway here is we don't want to make a $50,000 or $100,000 decision based on gut, based on emotions. Do the hard math and make it make sense financially, and then find someone else to challenge that. If you ask your wife, she's probably going to say no every time.
Maybe don't ask your wife. Maybe ask somebody else. does it make sense financially uh to buy this and honestly if you talk to you know if you're an excavator and you buy a piece of equipment go talk to other excavators and ask them who own equipment what it's like like ask them real questions about it right so one thing you can use is uh you can you can calculate your annual net benefit what's the net benefit of using this equipment so it's going to be additional annual gross profit can we do more work you know if we can instead of hand digging 50 holes now we have a piece of equipment we can you know we can do it half the time, which allows us to do an extra three jobs a month, then that's an additional gross profit.
So you take your annual gross profit plus your annual cost savings. Instead of paying 3K a month, we only pay 1500. And then you subtract any additional operating expenses. What does it cost to operate? Manpower, moving, all that stuff. And then that's your annual net benefit. So that's how you calculate your annual net benefit. And then to calculate your return on investment. It's your annual net benefit divided by your initial investment times 100. That's your simple annual ROI percentage that gives you an idea of what that's going to be.
And then you can calculate your payback period, which is your initial investment, divided by your annual net benefits. And that equals how many years to break even, right? So here's a quick example on that $50,000 initial investment. Your additional annual gross profit is an extra 40K. Your additional annual operating expenses is 10,000. So your annual net benefit is an additional $30,000 a year. So your ROI is 30,000 divided by 50 times 100. That's a 60% annual ROI. The payback is going to be 50,000 divided by 30,000 equals 1.67 years or 20 months.
So it would pay for itself in roughly 20 months. And here's the most important question that I was saying before, what if the investment only produces half of what you expect? Does it still make sense? So if the additional gross profit drops from 40,000 to 20,000, but expenses stay at 10,000, then your ROI drops to 20% and your payback increases from 20 months to five years. So it can, it can definitely make a big impact, right? If you get half of what you expect and then your leads drop off and you're stuck with a $1,500 a month payment, and then you got to pay that for an additional two to three years because you're not making any money, like it's a pure expense, that's a painful place to be, right?
So run the numbers twice. Once using your realistic expectations, this is what I think we can do. And then once using a 50% or half of your projected results and somewhere in between there, it needs to make sense. So if that half, it doesn't make, it absolutely doesn't make sense at half, you know, but it makes sense at like 75%, percent, that's going to be a gamble, right? If it makes complete sense, even at half operating expenses, then by all means, go for it, right? But some of you are basing it on 100% expectancy of return of investment and all this, and then you get stuck at 50% and you're screwed.
And this happens all the time. People buy stuff, especially vehicles, trucks, you know, you know what I'm talking about. You gotta go buy that brand new truck and jack it up. Nevermind, I'll keep my mouth shut. So that's not even including like depreciation, right? So you can get super nerdy and like add in all that stuff too, if you really want to, but if you keep it simple and just do what I told you, it's going to give you a really, really good idea of whether or not it makes sense. All right, guys, thanks for hanging out with me.
That's the end of the episode. You know where to find me on the socials. You can go look there. Make sure you join us on school. The link's in the bio. You go there, all our resources and information is on school now. It makes it super easy to get access to it and access to myself. So if you do need help in your business, maybe you can't afford coaching, you can still get access there and get real help in the school community. Until next time we meet, guys, remember one thing, profit is not a dirty word.
Podbean